Studies in the Ethics of Coordination and Climate Change

Campbell, Tim , Torpman, Olle , Bykvist, Krister , Andric, Vuko , Klint Jensen, Karsten , Hormio, Säde , Budolfson, Mark, Blomberg, Olle, Kaczmarek, Patrick, Nefsky, Petersson, Björn, Julia, Schwenkenbecher, Anne & Tenenbaum, Sergio | 2024

Working papers 2024:1-9

Abstract

There is no clear and convincing ethical account of who has a duty to do exactly what with respect to climate change. One major reason is that a convincing ethics addressing collective harm problems has yet to be formulated. A collective harm problem involves many people acting in a way that leads to serious harm, but each individual’s contribution is miniscule. Our joint carbon emissions causing climate change is a particularly complex collective harm problem. The research project Ethics of Coordination aims to formulate a new approach to addressing collective harm problems, an ethics of coordination that incorporates both direct individual duties and collective duties, and to apply this approach to climate change. This would have important practical implications. It would not only provide clearer ethical guidance and efficiency in fighting climate change but would also allow us to address collective harm problems more generally. This is the first volume in our preprint series. It collects nine contributions from project members and affiliated researchers.

2024:1 How Might Collective Duties be Grounded in Individual Duties?
Vuko Andrić
Read more >

2024:2 Collective Blameworthiness and the Group’s Perspective
Olle Blomberg & Björn Petersson 
Read more >

2024:3 Why Morality and Other Forms of Normativity are Sometimes Dramatically Directly Collectively Self-Defeating
Mark Budolfson
Read more >

2024:4 Having It Both Ways? On the Prospects for a Cooperation-FriendlyHarmonization in Moral Hi-Lo Cases
Krister Bykvist & Karsten Klint Jensen
Read more >

2024:5 Improving Lives and Avoiding Harm: A Critical Responseto Harm-Based Arguments for Climate Anti-Natalism
Tim Campbell & Patrick Kaczmarek
Read more >

2024:6 Droplets of Detriment and Pint-Sized Profits: Small Contributions to Collective Outcomes
Säde Hormio
Read more >

2024:7 Rescuing Ourselves from the Pond Analogy
Julia Nefsky & Sergio Tenenbaum
Read more >

2024:8 Solving Collective Action Problems? We-reasoning as Moral Deliberation
Anne Schwenkenbecher
Read more >

2024:9 Responsibility-Based Reasons to Act in Collective Impact Cases
Olle Torpman
Read more >

 

pdf document - Free of charge
Download

Working papers 2024:1-9

Abstract

There is no clear and convincing ethical account of who has a duty to do exactly what with respect to climate change. One major reason is that a convincing ethics addressing collective harm problems has yet to be formulated. A collective harm problem involves many people acting in a way that leads to serious harm, but each individual’s contribution is miniscule. Our joint carbon emissions causing climate change is a particularly complex collective harm problem. The research project Ethics of Coordination aims to formulate a new approach to addressing collective harm problems, an ethics of coordination that incorporates both direct individual duties and collective duties, and to apply this approach to climate change. This would have important practical implications. It would not only provide clearer ethical guidance and efficiency in fighting climate change but would also allow us to address collective harm problems more generally. This is the first volume in our preprint series. It collects nine contributions from project members and affiliated researchers.

2024:1 How Might Collective Duties be Grounded in Individual Duties?
Vuko Andrić
Read more >

2024:2 Collective Blameworthiness and the Group’s Perspective
Olle Blomberg & Björn Petersson 
Read more >

2024:3 Why Morality and Other Forms of Normativity are Sometimes Dramatically Directly Collectively Self-Defeating
Mark Budolfson
Read more >

2024:4 Having It Both Ways? On the Prospects for a Cooperation-FriendlyHarmonization in Moral Hi-Lo Cases
Krister Bykvist & Karsten Klint Jensen
Read more >

2024:5 Improving Lives and Avoiding Harm: A Critical Responseto Harm-Based Arguments for Climate Anti-Natalism
Tim Campbell & Patrick Kaczmarek
Read more >

2024:6 Droplets of Detriment and Pint-Sized Profits: Small Contributions to Collective Outcomes
Säde Hormio
Read more >

2024:7 Rescuing Ourselves from the Pond Analogy
Julia Nefsky & Sergio Tenenbaum
Read more >

2024:8 Solving Collective Action Problems? We-reasoning as Moral Deliberation
Anne Schwenkenbecher
Read more >

2024:9 Responsibility-Based Reasons to Act in Collective Impact Cases
Olle Torpman
Read more >